You paid your premiums so a bad day would not turn into a financial crisis, and it is frustrating to watch the company argue about what it owes.
Scott Templeton of Templeton Law Firm is a San Angelo insurance dispute lawyer for homeowners, drivers, and business owners across West Texas who disagree with their own insurer about a loss, the coverage, or the way the claim was handled.
He has spent 25+ years untangling contracts, policy language, and Texas insurance law, and he can take over the fight with the adjuster.
Before you accept a number or sign a release, call +1 (325) 482-9120 to schedule a consultation with Scott.
What Counts as an Insurance Dispute in Texas?
An insurance dispute is any disagreement between you and your insurer that the normal claim process has not fixed. Most fall into one of three groups, and the type of disagreement shapes which tool fits.
| Type of Dispute | What It Looks Like | Common Path to Resolve It |
| Amount of loss | The insurer accepts the claim but pays too little for your roof, car, or inventory | Appraisal, negotiation, or a lawsuit |
| Coverage | The insurer says an exclusion applies or the policy does not cover the event | Negotiation or a lawsuit, since appraisal usually cannot decide coverage |
| Claim handling | The insurer misrepresents the policy, ignores evidence, or stalls | A lawsuit under the Texas Insurance Code, often joined with a contract claim |
A single claim can involve all three. A hail claim can start as an argument over how many roof squares were damaged and end as a fight over whether older damage is excluded.
Reading the Policy Itself
Coverage disputes are won or lost in the policy wording. The declarations page, exclusions, and endorsements added at renewal can change what is covered, so Scott starts with the complete policy, not the summary the insurer sends with a denial.
Depreciation and Matching Fights
Many amount-of-loss disputes come down to depreciation or matching. Under a replacement cost policy, the insurer may first pay only the actual cash value and hold back depreciation until repairs are done, and the size of that holdback is often contested.
Matching comes up when hail damages part of a roof or one wall of siding, and the question becomes whether new materials have to match what remains. The policy language usually decides that answer.
When the problem is an outright denial or a claim that has gone unanswered, Templeton Law Firm also handles denied insurance claims and delayed claims, which follow their own deadlines.

Should You Use Appraisal or File a Lawsuit?
Appraisal is usually the faster choice when the only argument is about dollars, and a lawsuit is usually necessary when the argument is about coverage or conduct. Choosing the wrong one, or using them in the wrong order, can limit what you recover later.
How Appraisal Works
Many homeowners and auto policies include an appraisal clause. According to the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI), you and the insurer each hire an appraiser, and the two appraisers choose an umpire.
An agreement between any two of the three sets the amount of loss. You typically pay your own appraiser and half of the umpire's costs.
A newer Texas law, Insurance Code Chapter 1813, requires most personal auto and residential property policies to include an appraisal provision that either side can invoke. Commercial policies and Texas Windstorm Insurance Association policies follow their own terms.
What Appraisal Can and Cannot Do
Appraisal can settle a disagreement over how much the damage costs to repair. It generally cannot decide whether the policy covers the loss in the first place.
The Texas Supreme Court has held that an insurer's timely payment of an appraisal award can defeat later contract and bad faith claims over the amount. The same court held that paying the award does not erase penalties for paying late under the Texas prompt payment statute.
Because the order of steps matters, Scott reviews the whole claim before recommending appraisal.
What Is the 61-Day Notice Before Suing an Insurer?
For most property claims caused by weather, you must give the insurer written notice at least 61 days before filing suit. Texas Insurance Code Section 542A.003 sets that rule for claims arising from hail, wind, flood, tornadoes, wildfires, and other forces of nature.
The notice must explain what the insurer did wrong, state the amount owed, and list the attorney's fees incurred so far. A late or incomplete notice can reduce the fees you can recover, so the details matter.
What Happens After Notice Is Sent
Sending notice opens a short window for the insurer to respond. Under the same chapter, the insurer can ask in writing, within 30 days, to inspect, photograph, or evaluate the property, and the 61 days give both sides a chance to settle before a lawsuit is filed.
When Notice Is Not Required
The 61-day rule does not apply if there is not enough time left before the lawsuit deadline, or if the claim is raised as a counterclaim. That exception protects people who come to a lawyer late, but it is not a reason to wait.
Can You Have a Dispute With Your Own Auto Insurer After a Crash?
Yes, and these disputes are common after serious accidents. Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage (UM/UIM) is part of your own policy, yet your insurer will argue about the at-fault driver's responsibility and the value of your injuries just as the other side would.
Why UIM Claims Work Differently
In Texas, an underinsured motorist insurer generally does not have to pay until the other driver's liability and the amount of your damages are established. In practice, that can mean proving the injury case against your own insurer.
Your policy also requires you to cooperate, which can include a recorded statement or signed medical authorizations. Cooperation is a duty, but it does not require handing over unlimited records, so it helps to have a lawyer set the boundaries.
This is where Templeton Law Firm's two sides meet. Scott handles personal injury claims and insurance litigation, so he can value the injury and challenge the insurer in the same case.

Health and Disability Coverage Through Work
Disputes over health or disability coverage provided through an employer usually follow federal law, not Texas law. Most of these plans fall under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), which requires you to go through the plan's internal appeal before suing.
Why the Appeal Record Matters
Under U.S. Department of Labor claim rules, group health and disability plans must give you at least 180 days to appeal a denial. The record built during that appeal often becomes the main evidence a federal court reviews, so the appeal deserves the same care as a lawsuit.
Health plans regulated by Texas instead of ERISA follow a different track. When one of those plans denies care and the internal appeal fails, you can ask for an external review by an independent reviewer who does not work for the insurer.
How Does an Insurance Lawsuit Move Forward?
Most insurance lawsuits follow a predictable path, and many settle before trial. Knowing the stages helps you decide when to push and when to negotiate.
- Policy and claim review. Scott reads the full policy, the adjuster's estimates, and every letter you received.
- Pre-suit notice. For weather claims, the 61-day notice goes out with the amount owed.
- Filing. The case is filed in a Tom Green County court or the county where the property sits.
- Discovery. The insurer has to turn over much of its claim file, which can show how the decision was made.
- Mediation. Texas courts regularly send insurance cases to mediation with a neutral third party.
- Trial. If no fair agreement is reached, a judge or jury decides.
The claim file in step four tends to be the turning point. It can show estimates that were revised down, photos that were ignored, or reasons that changed over time.
Which Deadlines Can End an Insurance Dispute?
Several clocks can run at once, and the shortest one controls:
- Your policy's own deadlines for proof of loss, appraisal demands, or filing suit
- Two years for most claims under Chapter 541 of the Insurance Code, which covers unfair claim practices
- Four years for many breach of contract claims, though a policy can shorten that to as little as two years under Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 16.070
- 61 days of pre-suit notice for most weather-related property claims
- 180 days or more for internal appeals under employer health and disability plans
When a deadline starts can be its own point of argument. Bring the policy, every letter from the insurer, and any estimates or photos to your first meeting so the dates can be checked against the documents. A complete timeline also shows where the insurer's own deadlines were missed.

What Sets Templeton Law Firm Apart in Insurance Disputes
Few small firms handle injury cases, insurance litigation, and business disputes under one roof, and Templeton Law Firm does all three through one attorney. Scott Templeton starts every policy dispute with the contract itself, reading it line by line with an eye on what the insurer promised and what Texas law requires.
For a policyholder, that means someone who has seen how claims get valued, trimmed, and defended is now reading the file for you. Scott also explains the likely cost and timeline of each option before you choose one.
Clients work with the firm because:
- Scott handles your case personally. You will not be handed off to someone else for the important decisions.
- He knows both sides of a claim. Experience with injury cases and insurance lawsuits helps him spot when a valuation is off.
- He is local. Scott is a San Angelo native and Angelo State University graduate who has practiced in West Texas for more than two decades.
- Help is available in Spanish. The attorney and staff are bilingual.
Every dispute turns on its own policy and facts, and no lawyer can promise an outcome. Call +1 (325) 482-9120 or send the office a message to schedule a time to go over your policy with Scott.
Talk to a San Angelo Insurance Dispute Lawyer

Your insurer has adjusters, appraisers, and its own legal team working its side of the claim. You should have someone who knows the policy and Texas law just as well.
Call Templeton Law Firm at +1 (325) 482-9120 to set up a meeting with Scott Templeton.
The office is at 905 S. Abe Street in San Angelo, open Monday through Friday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
FAQs: San Angelo Insurance Disputes
Here are other questions policyholders in San Angelo ask about disputes with their insurers.
Can I hire a lawyer while my insurance claim is still open?
Yes. You do not have to wait for a final decision to get legal help in Texas. Bringing in a lawyer while the claim is open can help you avoid statements, proof-of-loss forms, or partial payments that later limit your options.
Is a public adjuster the same as an insurance dispute lawyer?
No. A licensed public adjuster in Texas can document damage and negotiate the amount of a property claim, but cannot give legal advice or file a lawsuit. A lawyer can handle coverage questions, Insurance Code claims, and litigation, and some cases use both.
Can I dispute the total-loss value my own insurer gave for my car?
Yes. If your insurer's total-loss offer seems low, you can challenge it with comparable vehicle listings and repair records, and many Texas auto policies allow appraisal to settle the amount. Ask for the valuation report the insurer relied on, since errors in mileage or options are common.
What is the difference between an insurance dispute and bad faith?
An insurance dispute is any disagreement over a claim, while bad faith means the insurer had no reasonable basis for its position or handled the claim unfairly. Many disputes are honest disagreements over value. A bad faith claim can open the door to additional damages under Texas law.
Can a business owner in San Angelo bring an insurance dispute over a commercial policy?
Yes. Business owners can challenge underpaid property, business interruption, and liability coverage claims. Commercial policies fall outside the newer Texas appraisal law for personal auto and home policies, so the policy's own terms and Texas Insurance Code protections guide the process.